The Turkish Constitutional Court (the “Constitutional Court”) has annulled the provision requiring the court-determined market value to be used as the basis for exercising the statutory right of pre-emption. The decision dated 16 July 2026, numbered E.2026/23, K.2026/162, was published in the Official Gazette on 6 November 2026.
The decision is particularly significant for the protection of the parties’ economic interests in transactions involving jointly owned real estate and the determination of the applicable purchase price in pending pre-emption proceedings.
- How Had the Market Value Approach to the Right of Pre-emption Changed?
The statutory right of pre-emption (şufa hakkı) entitles a co-owner of immovable property held in co-ownership to acquire a share in priority to a third party where another co-owner sells their share to that third party.
Prior to the amendment introduced to Article 734 of Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 (the “TCC”) by Law No. 7571 dated 24 December 2025, the exercise of the right of pre-emption was based on the purchase price agreed upon between the parties to the sale.
The amendment replaced this approach by requiring the holder of the right of pre-emption to deposit the market value determined by the court, together with the land registry expenses attributable to the purchaser. The new rules were also made applicable to proceedings initiated before the amendment entered into force.
- Why Did the Constitutional Court Find the Market Value Approach Unconstitutional?
The decisive consideration in the Constitutional Court’s assessment was that exercising the right of pre-emption on the basis of market value could alter the contractual terms agreed upon by the parties and undermine the balance between their respective property rights.
The right of pre-emption allows its holder to step into the position of the third-party purchaser. However, applying a court-determined market value may result in the transfer of the relevant share at a price different from the original purchase price.
For example, where a share in immovable property is purchased for TRY 5 million but its market value is subsequently determined by the court to be TRY 7 million, the third-party purchaser could receive an amount exceeding the price originally paid. Conversely, if the market value is determined to be TRY 4 million, the purchaser could incur a financial loss.
The Constitutional Court held that such outcomes could prevent a fair balance from being struck between the parties’ interests arising from their property rights. Accordingly, it found the market value provision incompatible with Articles 5 and 35 of the Turkish Constitution.
- Scope and Effective Date of the Annulment
The Constitutional Court’s annulment was not limited to the expression “market value”. It also extended to Article 734(2) of the TCC in its entirety, as well as the transitional provision requiring the 2025 amendments to apply to proceedings initiated before their entry into force.
Nevertheless, considering the potential legal gap arising from the annulment, the Constitutional Court postponed its entry into effect for nine months.
Accordingly, the annulment will take effect on 6 August 2027, and the existing statutory framework will remain applicable until that date.
Importantly, the annulment will not automatically reinstate the purchase-price approach that applied before the 2025 amendment. Further legislative action will therefore be important to establish a clear legal framework.
- How Will the Decision Affect Pending Pre-emption Proceedings?
One of the decision’s most significant implications concerns the uncertainty surrounding the applicable pricing mechanism in pending pre-emption proceedings.
Although the existing provisions will remain in force until 6 August 2027, the rules applicable thereafter will depend on any legislative amendments adopted in the interim.
This is particularly relevant to the determination of the pre-emption price, the deposit of that amount with the court, and the protection of the parties’ economic interests in ongoing litigation.
From a transactional perspective, purchasers of shares in co-owned real estate should assess potential pre-emption risks before completing an acquisition. Similarly, co-owners intending to exercise their statutory right of pre-emption must remain mindful of the applicable statutory limitation periods, the expiry of which may result in the loss of that right.
- Assessment and Conclusion
The Constitutional Court’s decision underscores the importance of preserving the economic terms agreed upon by the parties and maintaining a fair balance between their respective property rights when the statutory right of pre-emption is exercised.
While the decision does not abolish the statutory right of pre-emption itself, it will alter the existing legal framework governing the determination of the price payable upon its exercise.
Accordingly, legislative developments leading up to 6 August 2027 should be closely monitored, particularly in relation to pending pre-emption proceedings and transfers of shares in co-owned real estate.
Best Regards,
DT Law